← Home  |  SR Overview  |  Interactive Compare

Baseline Results

LumbarSR: A Paired Clinical CT and Photon-Counting Micro-CT Dataset for Human Lumbar Vertebrae

Experimental Setup

Additional Baselines

Method Status Result Slot
ESRGAN Image metrics + morphometry released Filled on 2026-04-06
SwinIR Image metrics + morphometry released Filled on 2026-04-06

Registration Evaluation

We report registration quality within the released BoneMask ROI using Dice, HD95, and HD. These metrics are provided as a practical reference for the final registration quality.

Method ROI Dice ↑ HD95 ↓ HD ↓
ANTs rigid baseline (195X_195Y_500Z_B) BoneMask ROI 0.9826 ± 0.0017 0.2266 ± 0.0131 mm 1.1476 ± 0.5960 mm
ANTs rigid baseline (586X_586Y_500Z_B) BoneMask ROI 0.9811 ± 0.0023 0.2887 ± 0.0358 mm 0.9095 ± 0.2725 mm
ANTs rigid baseline (overall) BoneMask ROI 0.9818 ± 0.0021 0.2576 ± 0.0411 mm 1.0285 ± 0.4785 mm

Bone Morphometry

The public benchmark pages now report the currently released subset (`Micro-PCCT`, registered clinical CT baseline, `SRCNN`, `UNet`, `ESRGAN`, and `SwinIR`) for ROI-based bone morphometry.

195X_195Y_1000Z_S

Method / Data BV/TV Tb.Th (mm) Tb.Sp (mm) Tb.N (mm^-1)
Micro-PCCT reference 0.2208 ± 0.01740.2573 ± 0.01410.3647 ± 0.01920.8608 ± 0.0881
Registered clinical CT baseline 0.0055 ± 0.00290.5837 ± 0.11794.1319 ± 1.13140.0097 ± 0.0056
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.2125 / 0.03125+0.3761 / 0.03125+3.8776 / 0.03125-0.8398 / 0.03125
Nearest 0.0055 ± 0.00290.5837 ± 0.11794.1319 ± 1.13140.0097 ± 0.0056
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.2125 / 0.03125+0.3761 / 0.03125+3.8776 / 0.03125-0.8398 / 0.03125
SRCNN 0.0605 ± 0.02120.7673 ± 0.08650.9809 ± 0.24480.0773 ± 0.0202
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.1556 / 0.03125+0.5861 / 0.03125+0.5512 / 0.03125-0.7762 / 0.03125
UNet 0.0931 ± 0.02350.4324 ± 0.05500.4565 ± 0.05740.2133 ± 0.0346
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.1217 / 0.03125+0.1907 / 0.03125+0.0951 / 0.03125-0.6357 / 0.03125
ESRGAN 0.1330 ± 0.02390.2740 ± 0.01120.3941 ± 0.02490.4841 ± 0.0773
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.0878 / 0.03125+0.0167 / 0.03125+0.0293 / 0.09375-0.3767 / 0.03125
SwinIR 0.0415 ± 0.01400.7371 ± 0.08451.3594 ± 0.35290.0549 ± 0.0127
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.1793 / 0.03125+0.4798 / 0.03125+0.9947 / 0.03125-0.8059 / 0.03125

586X_586Y_1000Z_S

Method / Data BV/TV Tb.Th (mm) Tb.Sp (mm) Tb.N (mm^-1)
Micro-PCCT reference 0.2208 ± 0.01740.2573 ± 0.01410.3647 ± 0.01920.8608 ± 0.0881
Registered clinical CT baseline 0.0026 ± 0.00180.5338 ± 0.13225.0502 ± 1.87190.0053 ± 0.0044
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.2167 / 0.03125+0.2665 / 0.03125+5.0664 / 0.03125-0.8493 / 0.03125
Nearest 0.0026 ± 0.00180.5338 ± 0.13225.0502 ± 1.87190.0053 ± 0.0044
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.2167 / 0.03125+0.2665 / 0.03125+5.0664 / 0.03125-0.8493 / 0.03125
SRCNN 0.1271 ± 0.02040.6565 ± 0.07390.4540 ± 0.04250.1928 ± 0.0104
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.0864 / 0.03125+0.4665 / 0.03125+0.0593 / 0.09375-0.6719 / 0.03125
UNet 0.1227 ± 0.02540.4639 ± 0.04670.4421 ± 0.04590.2624 ± 0.0300
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.0920 / 0.03125+0.2314 / 0.03125+0.0863 / 0.03125-0.5960 / 0.03125
ESRGAN 0.1506 ± 0.02090.2730 ± 0.00890.3710 ± 0.01600.5511 ± 0.0702
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.0702 / 0.03125+0.0156 / 0.03125+0.0063 / 0.40625-0.3097 / 0.03125
SwinIR 0.0486 ± 0.01440.4010 ± 0.02030.9216 ± 0.20530.1198 ± 0.0305
Δ / p-value vs Micro-PCCT -0.1722 / 0.03125+0.1437 / 0.03125+0.5568 / 0.03125-0.7410 / 0.03125

The released BoneMask defines a consistent VOI for all public morphometry statistics; the public tables report BV/TV, Tb.Th, Tb.Sp, and Tb.N.

Quantitative Comparison Figure

Quantitative comparison of super-resolution baselines across objective metrics and bone morphometry

Summary figure of registration, image-quality, and trabecular morphometry comparisons across the released baselines. Open the PDF version for the full-resolution figure.

PSNR Results dB ↑

Small FOV (195μm × 195μm)

Method Full Masked
Raw Bone Soft Raw Bone Soft
Baseline21.9449±0.601518.9359±0.400717.2012±0.343511.8627±0.68468.8535±0.54377.1188±0.5422
UNet21.9449±0.601518.9359±0.400717.2012±0.343511.8627±0.68468.8535±0.54377.1188±0.5422
SRCNN23.6444±0.503420.0389±0.390918.0030±0.353412.8653±0.34599.2598±0.32027.2238±0.3015
ESRGAN21.8739±0.708818.7800±0.559217.0813±0.44459.7697±0.50646.6177±0.42234.9046±0.3837
SwinIR22.8177±0.588519.7247±0.424317.5512±0.336610.7463±0.37287.6232±0.34765.5052±0.2795
Nearest23.7416±0.541720.1053±0.418617.9961±0.356913.0394±0.35289.4029±0.30317.2937±0.2600

Large FOV (586μm × 586μm)

Method Full Masked
Raw Bone Soft Raw Bone Soft
Baseline22.0106±0.592818.9804±0.365717.3008±0.302612.0416±0.60359.0115±0.44467.3319±0.4541
UNet22.0106±0.592818.9804±0.365717.3008±0.302612.0416±0.60359.0115±0.44467.3319±0.4541
SRCNN23.9935±0.579020.3074±0.421818.0655±0.366713.1820±0.38089.4958±0.27197.2539±0.2084
ESRGAN22.6371±0.535019.2183±0.434217.4409±0.369710.4862±0.32207.0362±0.30905.2592±0.3222
SwinIR23.3147±0.532920.2197±0.350617.8842±0.323011.2070±0.28518.0537±0.27075.7589±0.2208
Nearest23.7139±0.539520.1946±0.406317.9976±0.363213.0295±0.34409.5101±0.25687.3131±0.2268

SSIM Results ↑

Small FOV (195μm × 195μm)

Method Full Masked
Raw Bone Soft Raw Bone Soft
Baseline0.9239±0.00300.9432±0.00350.9467±0.00320.9239±0.00300.9432±0.00350.9467±0.0032
UNet0.9345±0.00510.9489±0.00320.9499±0.00320.9345±0.00510.9489±0.00320.9499±0.0032
SRCNN0.9309±0.00440.9479±0.00330.9493±0.00330.9309±0.00440.9479±0.00330.9493±0.0033
ESRGAN0.9294±0.00530.9438±0.00380.9448±0.00380.8224±0.04140.8216±0.04260.8241±0.0421
SwinIR0.9222±0.00330.9414±0.00360.9460±0.00320.9222±0.00330.9414±0.00360.9460±0.0032
Nearest0.9309±0.00440.9479±0.00330.9493±0.00330.9309±0.00440.9479±0.00330.9493±0.0033

Large FOV (586μm × 586μm)

Method Full Masked
Raw Bone Soft Raw Bone Soft
Baseline0.9240±0.00370.9445±0.00350.9475±0.00310.9240±0.00370.9445±0.00350.9475±0.0031
UNet0.9371±0.00410.9489±0.00310.9500±0.00320.9371±0.00410.9489±0.00310.9500±0.0032
SRCNN0.9310±0.00460.9473±0.00340.9491±0.00330.9310±0.00460.9473±0.00340.9491±0.0033
ESRGAN0.9304±0.00510.9450±0.00350.9462±0.00330.8231±0.03860.8222±0.03970.8250±0.0391
SwinIR0.9214±0.00420.9426±0.00360.9472±0.00320.9214±0.00420.9426±0.00360.9472±0.0032
Nearest0.9310±0.00460.9473±0.00340.9491±0.00330.9310±0.00460.9473±0.00340.9491±0.0033

MAE Results ↓

Small FOV (195μm × 195μm)

Method Full Masked
Raw Bone Soft Raw Bone Soft
Baseline0.0143±0.00150.0182±0.00160.0208±0.00160.1455±0.01750.1858±0.02240.2132±0.0255
UNet0.0117±0.00120.0150±0.00130.0175±0.00140.1395±0.00670.1798±0.01160.2091±0.0144
SRCNN0.0122±0.00120.0152±0.00130.0176±0.00140.1376±0.00670.1780±0.01050.2070±0.0124
ESRGAN0.0143±0.00170.0185±0.00200.0213±0.00210.2213±0.01680.3045±0.02530.3514±0.0301
SwinIR0.0140±0.00140.0176±0.00160.0201±0.00150.2062±0.01040.2810±0.01600.3210±0.0193
Nearest0.0122±0.00120.0152±0.00130.0176±0.00140.1376±0.00670.1780±0.01050.2070±0.0124

Large FOV (586μm × 586μm)

Method Full Masked
Raw Bone Soft Raw Bone Soft
Baseline0.0140±0.00150.0178±0.00160.0203±0.00150.1389±0.01520.1773±0.01900.2020±0.0211
UNet0.0116±0.00120.0151±0.00130.0176±0.00150.1383±0.00590.1814±0.00920.2118±0.0109
SRCNN0.0121±0.00120.0153±0.00140.0178±0.00150.1386±0.00660.1789±0.00960.2080±0.0111
ESRGAN0.0135±0.00140.0171±0.00150.0197±0.00160.2062±0.01040.2822±0.01860.3247±0.0239
SwinIR0.0135±0.00130.0166±0.00140.0189±0.00140.1986±0.00790.2690±0.01170.3073±0.0150
Nearest0.0121±0.00120.0153±0.00140.0178±0.00150.1386±0.00660.1789±0.00960.2080±0.0111

Methods Description


Results updated: April 2026 | For questions, contact zhangrp@sjtu.edu.cn